How to Split Holidays: Holiday Schedule Options for North Dakota Parents

How to split holidays: holiday schedule options for North Dakota parents

By: Sapir Sela

There are six common ways to split holidays after divorce: alternate holidays by year, split the holiday itself, divide school breaks, assign fixed holidays to one parent, pair holidays together, or celebrate twice. Most families combine several of these. The right mix depends on how far apart you live, your children’s ages, and the traditions that matter most to each side of the family.

The holiday season is supposed to be about celebration, family traditions, and making memories with your children. For separated parents, it can also bring uncertainty and stress. One of the most common questions I hear this time of year is: “Who gets the kids for the holidays?”

In North Dakota, every parenting plan must include a schedule for holidays, days off from school, birthdays, and vacations. N.D.C.C. § 14-09-30. That leaves a lot of room for parents to choose what works. Below are the options I see most often, with the pros and cons of each. If you are building or revising a plan, our Family Law Attorneys can help.

1. Alternating Holidays by Year

Alternating holidays means one parent has a holiday in even-numbered years and the other parent has it in odd-numbered years. It is the most common holiday arrangement because it is simple, predictable, and equal over time.

Example: Mom has Thanksgiving in even years and Dad has it in odd years. The next year, they switch.

Works best when: Parents live far apart, or the children are old enough to handle going a full year between a holiday with each parent.

Watch out for: A parent may go a whole year without a particular holiday. Many families soften this by pairing it with the next option for the biggest holidays.

2. Splitting the Holiday Itself

Splitting the holiday means both parents see the children on the same holiday, usually by dividing the day or the holiday period into two halves. Parents typically rotate which half they get each year.

Example: One parent has Christmas Eve from noon until 10:00 a.m. Christmas morning. The other has Christmas Day from 10:00 a.m. until the next morning. They swap halves every year.

Works best when: Parents live close to each other and both want to be part of every major holiday.

Watch out for: Splitting adds an exchange in the middle of a busy day. In a Fargo winter, plan for weather and travel time, and set a clear exchange location.

3. Dividing Winter Break and Other School Breaks

Dividing school breaks means each parent receives part of a longer school vacation, such as winter break, spring break, or Thanksgiving break. Winter break is usually split in half, with the halves rotating each year so each parent has Christmas every other year.

Example: Winter break runs from the day school lets out until the day before school resumes. In even years, Parent A has the first half (including Christmas) and Parent B has the second half (including New Year’s). In odd years, they switch.

Works best when: Families want extended, uninterrupted time for travel or visits with relatives.

Watch out for: School calendars change each year, so define the break by the school calendar rather than fixed dates, and say exactly when the midpoint exchange happens.

4. Assigning Fixed Holidays to One Parent

A fixed holiday is assigned to the same parent every year rather than alternating. This works for holidays that clearly belong to one parent or one side of the family.

Mother’s Day and Father’s Day: Almost always assigned to the corresponding parent every year.

Each parent’s birthday: The parent may have a few hours or an evening with the children on their own birthday.

Religious or cultural holidays: If only one parent observes a holiday, it often makes sense to give that holiday to that parent every year.

Long-standing family traditions: If one side of the family always hosts a Fourth of July reunion at the lake, parents may agree that holiday stays with that parent.

5. Pairing Holidays Together

Pairing holidays means grouping holidays so each parent gets one major holiday each year. The most familiar version pairs Thanksgiving with Christmas: whoever has Thanksgiving does not have Christmas, and the pairing flips the next year.

Example: In even years, Dad has Thanksgiving and Mom has Christmas. In odd years, Mom has Thanksgiving and Dad has Christmas.

Works best when: Parents want each holiday season to feel balanced, so neither parent goes the entire season without a major holiday.

Watch out for: Holidays carry different weight in different families. A Thanksgiving-for-Christmas trade only feels fair if both holidays matter similarly to both households.

6. Celebrating Twice

Celebrating twice means each household holds its own version of the holiday on a different day. Christmas does not have to be celebrated on December 25 to be special. Thanksgiving dinner can take place the following weekend. Birthdays can be celebrated in both homes.

Many families combine this with alternating or splitting. The parent without the children on the actual day plans a “second Christmas” or a second Thanksgiving dinner during their own time.

Other Options Worth Considering

Three-day weekends follow the weekend: Memorial Day, Labor Day, and similar Monday holidays attach to whichever parent has that weekend, which avoids extra exchanges.

Keep the regular schedule: For minor holidays, some parents simply let the regular schedule apply. This only works when both parents are flexible.

Halloween by the hour: Because trick-or-treating is a short window, some parents split the evening or alternate years.

Children’s birthdays: Options include alternating years, giving the non-scheduled parent a few hours on the day, or letting each household celebrate separately each year.

Sample Holiday Schedule

Here is an example of how several of these approaches can work together in one parenting plan:

Holiday Even years Odd years
Thanksgiving (Wed. 6 p.m. to Fri. 6 p.m.) Parent A Parent B
Christmas Eve (Dec. 24, noon, to Dec. 25, 10 a.m.) Parent B Parent A
Christmas Day (Dec. 25, 10 a.m., to Dec. 26, 10 a.m.) Parent A Parent B
School Winter break, first half Parent B Parent A
School Winter break, second half Parent A Parent B
Easter (Sat. 6 p.m. to Sun. 6 p.m.) Parent B Parent A
Fourth of July Parent A Parent B
Mother’s Day / Father’s Day Mother / Father every year Mother / Father every year
Memorial Day and Labor Day weekends Follows regular weekend Follows regular weekend

Details That Make Any Holiday Schedule Work

Whichever method you choose, the details prevent most disputes. When I draft parenting plans, I make sure the holiday section answers these questions:

Exact times: “Christmas Eve” can mean noon, 5:00 p.m., or after church. Write the start and end times.

Exchanges: Where the children are exchanged and who drives.

Priority: Holiday time generally overrides the regular schedule. Say so, and say whether holidays also override summer vacation weeks.

Overlaps: What happens when a holiday falls on a school day, next to a regular weekend, or on the same day as another holiday or birthday.

Travel: How much notice a parent must give before traveling with the children over a holiday.

The more specific your plan is, the less room there is for disagreement later.

How to Choose the Right Holiday Split for Your Family

There is no single holiday schedule that works for every family. When helping parents choose, I ask about:

Distance: Parents across town can split a day. Parents in different states usually alternate years or divide breaks.

Children’s ages: Young children often do better with shorter gaps between time with each parent.

Traditions: Which holidays matter most to each household and to extended family.

Work schedules: Parents in health care, law enforcement, agriculture, or retail may work holidays and need a schedule built around that.

Above all, avoid putting children in the position of choosing where to spend a holiday or resolving disagreements between their parents. The goal should not be to win the holiday. It should be to create a holiday season your children can enjoy.

If your current holiday schedule is vague or causes the same argument every year, consider hiring a Family Law Attorney at SW&L to assist you in establishing or changing your holiday schedule.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s) About Splitting Holidays

What is the most common way to split holidays after divorce?

Alternating holidays by year is the most common approach. One parent has a holiday in even-numbered years and the other has it in odd-numbered years, so each parent gets every holiday every other year.

How do divorced or separated parents usually split Christmas?

The most common options are splitting Christmas Eve and Christmas Day and swapping each year, alternating the whole Christmas holiday by year, or dividing winter break in half with the half that includes Christmas rotating annually.

Can we celebrate a holiday on a different day?

Yes. Many families hold a second Thanksgiving dinner or Christmas morning on a different day. This works well when parents live far apart or when both families want a full celebration without rushing through an exchange.

Who gets Mother’s Day and Father’s Day?

Most parenting plans give Mother’s Day to the mother and Father’s Day to the father every year, regardless of whose regular weekend it is.

What holidays should a North Dakota parenting plan include?

Most plans cover Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and Christmas Day, New Year’s, Easter, Memorial Day, the Fourth of July, Labor Day, Halloween, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, the children’s birthdays, and school breaks. Add or remove any religious or cultural holidays that matter or don’t matter to your family.

Does the holiday schedule override the regular schedule?

Usually, yes. A holiday provision in a parenting plan generally takes priority over the regular weekly schedule for the holiday period. Check the exact wording of your judgment or parenting plan.

Need Help With Your Holiday Parenting Schedule?

At SW&L Attorneys, we understand that parenting time is about more than dates on a calendar. It is about family traditions, important memories, and your relationship with your children. Whether you are creating your first parenting plan or fixing a holiday schedule that isn’t working, our family law team can help you find an arrangement that fits your family.

Contact SW&L Attorneys to schedule a consultation and discuss your holiday parenting schedule.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Your parenting time rights and obligations depend on the specific language of your court order and the law that applies to your case.

Share:

More Posts:

DUI on a Bicycle | DUI Riding A Bicycle

A DUI For Riding A Bicycle?

Although most DUI and DWI cases involve automobiles, trucks, SUVs and sometimes motorcycles, there are sometimes cases involving other types of transportation, such as drunk biking. Here is an overview of how drunk driving laws treat bicycles in North Dakota.

Read More »

Send Us A Message

Scroll to Top

Client Inquiry Form

Click to load

Subscribe

* indicates required